|
Even France, Haven of
Smokers, Is Clearing the Air
January 03, 2008
PARIS — Overnight, conviviality has taken on an
entirely new meaning in France.Under a sweeping decree that took effect
Wednesday, smoking has been banned in every commercial corner of
“entertainment and conviviality” — from the toniest Parisian nightclub to
the humblest village cafe.
No matter that cigarette is a French word. Or that the great icons of French
creativity — Colette to Cocteau, Camus to Coco Chanel — all smoked. Or that
Paris boasts a Museum of Smoking. Or, in fact, that Paris has named a street
after Jean Nicot, the 16th-century French diplomat who took tobacco leaves
imported from America to Catherine de Medici to treat her migraines.
(Nicotine was named after him.)
The ban is the final step in a 2006 prohibition on smoking in public places,
which had granted postponements to restaurants, bars, discos, casinos and
other commercial pleasure enterprises so that they could better brace
themselves for smokelessness.
On Wednesday, Health Minister Roselyne Bachelot visited the high-ceilinged,
100-year-old Wepler brasserie in Paris and announced that there was
“perfect” compliance with the new rule.
“This is a new art de vivre,” she said, even as she warned of consequences
for “repeat offenders and rebels.” (Smokers who break the rules will face
fines of $100 to $661. Owners can be fined $198 to $1,100.) Michèle Alliot-Marie,
the interior minister, has told the country’s police that they do not have
to meet quotas in issuing fines and urged them to leave policing to
“competent” agents like public health inspectors.
The ban was supposed to take effect on Tuesday, but to preserve the New
Year’s Eve party spirit — and avoid the risk of violence — French smokers
were given an extra day of grace.
About 12 million French people — about 20 percent of the population — are
smokers, according to official figures, and more than 70,000 people die in
France every year from smoking-related illnesses and secondhand smoke.
The decree coincides with a broad Europe-wide nonsmoking movement that began
four years ago when Ireland banned smoking in public places. But here, there
are fierce pockets of resistance. Opponents say the ban signals the erosion
of French liberté. They say it is undemocratic because it was not passed
through Parliament but imposed by government decree.
Some owners of smaller bars and cafes contend that the ban is unfair because
it favors large, wealthy establishments that can take advantage of
loopholes. (Smoking is allowed in outdoor cafes and sophisticated indoor
“hermetically sealed areas, furnished with air-extraction systems.”) Indeed,
in writing the ban, little thought seemed to have been given to the
country’s 800 water-pipe tea houses, most of them extremely modest
enterprises owned by ethnic Arabs.
“We have sacrificed everything to open these little places, borrowing money
from our family members, using our cars and apartments as collateral, and
what’s going to happen to us?” said Tariq el-Hamri, the 33-year-old owner of
Dar Daffia (House of Hospitality), a water-pipe bar in Paris. “If the
government wants to have healthy people, it should stop selling cigarettes —
and alcohol.”
Mr. Hamri belongs to the Union of Hookah-Pipe Professionals, which plans to
challenge the ban in French courts and is lobbying for the same exception
for water-pipe smokers that is in effect in parts of the United States and
Canada. Expensive and space-consuming hermetic sealing is not an option for
most of them. “We are second-class citizens,” said Badri Helou, president of
the union, which was created last February and has 270 members. “The reason
you come to a water-pipe club is to smoke a water pipe. The mint tea and the
pastries come afterward. We cannot survive on them. It would be as if you go
to the movies and there’s no film — just popcorn.”
The Confederation of Tobacco Dealers, which represents 28,000 tobacconists
in France, has accused President Nicolas Sarkozy of duplicity.
During the presidential campaign last year, Mr. Sarkozy called for
flexibility to protect small businesses. “To ban smoking in places where
tobacco is sold, is somehow strange,” he said at the time, adding that there
should also be leniency for the small cafe-tabac in a village of 750 people
where “if it closes, there is nothing else.”
The confederation’s newsletter reprinted the opening two-page spread in a
recent issue of Paris-Match that shows Mr. Sarkozy at his desk, lighting a
cigar. “Is the Élysée Palace a private space where one can smoke or a place
of work?” said René Le Pape, president of the confederation. “The president
is setting a bad example. This is a provocation.”
For Mr. Le Pape, the ban signals the demise of a part of French culture. “It
means the destruction of village life,” he said. “What will happen to the
ritual of arriving at the cafe in the morning to read the morning paper over
a coffee and a cigarette?”
At Le Musée du Fumeur (The Museum of Smoking), there is concern that the
French may not be able to think as well without their cigarettes. “All our
great writers seem to have been smokers,” said Michka Seeliger-Chatelein,
one of the curators.
Still, there are efforts to keep a sense of humor. The cafe-restaurant Le
Fumoir (The Smoking Room) has made gifts of its signature ashtrays. The
cover of the current issue of Le Figaro Magazine retouched black and white
photos of Che Guevara, Jacques Brel, Brigitte Bardot and other passionate
smokers; they grip giant yellow buttercups instead of cigarettes between
their lips.
Most establishments seemed resigned to the ban. “We are not taking sides,”
said Colin Peter Field, the head bartender at the Hemingway Bar at the Ritz.
The bar will continue to sell 40 to 50 types of upscale cigars and is
studying plans to renovate its outdoor spaces to accommodate smokers.
“Once you’ve hung yourself,” Mr. Field said, “you’re not going to drown
yourself as well.”
|