Protein vs. Carbohydrates: A Weight-Loss Choice?
64 percent of Americans overweight or obese, the experts are debating what kinds
of foods put on the pounds. A balanced diet is the best way to prevent cancer
and heart disease while managing your weight.
What's making americans over- weight - the fat or the carbohydrates? People all
across the country are debating this issue. Do you lose weight by eliminating
most of the fat in your diet? Or do you shed those pounds by eliminating the
carbs and filling up on protein along with the saturated fat that comes with it?
"The answer is that you do neither," says Dr. Ritva Butrum, AICR's Vice
President for Research. "If you want to lose weight and stay healthy, you have
to eat fewer calories and exercise more, not simply cut whole categories of
foods from your diet."
The stakes in this debate are high because certain kinds of fat are linked to
higher long-term risk for cancer and other chronic diseases. On the other hand,
certain types of carbohydrates - particularly vegetables and fruit - are linked
to lowering that risk.
Choosing Healthful Fats and Carbs
Originally, health experts recommended reducing overall fat intake for heart
health and lower weight. However, recent research shows that some fats, used in
moderation, may have health benefits. Highly monounsaturated fats like olive and
canola oil are considered to be "heart healthy." Similarly, laboratory tests
suggest that omega-3 fatty acids (found in fatty fish, flaxseed, walnuts, and
canola and soybean oils) may help protect against cancer.
The questionable fats that some cancer research studies show to be hazardous are
saturated fats from animal proteins, such as red meat, whole milk and butter.
Health experts also advise avoiding products using "partially hydrogenated
vegetable oil," which contain harmful trans-fatty acids. Most margarine also
contains trans-fats, but after public pressure, some companies created versions
that do not; just check the labels.
At the same time, some scientists argue that refined carbohydrates like white
sugar, white rice and processed cereals raise insulin levels. In turn, this
leads to overeating and storage of excess fat at the waist and hips.
the other hand, unrefined carbohydrates such as whole wheat, brown rice and bran
cereals are digested more slowly and contain dietary fiber that solid research
evidence shows is linked to lower colon cancer risk.
The cancer-fighting vitamins and phytochemicals in fiber-rich vegetables,
fruits, whole grains and beans are another important health benefit. Dismissing
these foods simply because they are carbohydrates is short-sighted, Butrum says.
"Abandoning fruits and vegetables because they also contain carbohydrates could
prove disastrous to your health. A much wiser course is to eat moderate portions
of the types of carbohydrates and fats that are good for long-term health," she
AICR's rule of thumb makes it easy to choose the right foods in the right
proportions. Look at your plate: 2/3 (or more) should be filled with vegetables,
fruit, whole grains and beans; and 1/3 (or less) should hold lean animal
protein. This proportion of plant foods to meat and dairy will provide more
health-promoting fats and carbohydrates and fewer potentially harmful ones.
Eat Less and Exercise More for Weight Loss
For those concerned about weight loss, reducing portion size and increasing
physical activity level is the best course. Experts believe that promotional
practices such as "supersizing" and "value marketing" have confused people about
reasonable portion sizes. As a result they are consuming approximately 148 more
calories per day than they were two decades ago. These added calories could
amount to a weight gain of 15 pounds per year.
As you compose your meals to be 2/3 plant-based foods and 1/3 animal protein,
gradually reduce the size of portions. Ask yourself how many of those standard
serving sizes go into the portions you usually eat, and use them as a guide to
adjust your diet to be more healthful. Reduce your portion sizes gradually. Then
add more physical activity to your schedule, and weight loss will probably
If your weight does not decrease after a few weeks of reduced portion sizes and
increased activity, contact your physician or a registered dietitian for an
individualized plan. For more information about proportion and portion size,
call 1-800-843-8114 and request a copy of The New American Plate brochure.
Input by: The American Institute for Cancer Research is one of the
nation's largest cancer charities, focusing exclusively on the link between diet
and cancer. The Institute provides a wide range of education programs that help
millions of Americans learn to make dietary changes for lower cancer risk. AICR
also supports innovative research in cancer prevention and treatment at
universities, hospitals and research centers across the U.S. The Institute has
provided over $65 million in funding for research in diet, nutrition and cancer.
AICR is a member of the World Cancer Research Fund International.